Volume 21 - Issue 6

Review Article Biomedical Science and Research Biomedical Science and Research CC by Creative Commons, CC-BY

A Systematic Review of Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) Injuries in Soccer Players

*Corresponding author:Fatima Khurshid, Medical Doctor, Department of Radiation Oncology, Shifa International Hospital, ltd. Islamabad, Pakistan.

Received: March 11, 2024; Published: March 19, 2024

DOI: 10.34297/AJBSR.2024.21.002900

Abstract

Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) injuries are a major concern in soccer, affecting both players’ performance and well-being. This systematic analysis of ACL injuries in soccer players looks at the prevalence, risk factors, and preventative measures. The review found that ACL injuries are more common in older age groups among young male soccer players and are frequently induced by non-contact causes. Gender inequalities were also observed, with females having a higher rate of ACL injuries. Multi-component preventative programs, such as plyometrics and strength workouts, have shown successful in lowering ACL injuries. Further study is required to create targeted therapies and optimise preventative tactics. Understanding the risk factors and effective prevention techniques for ACL injuries in soccer players is critical to improving athlete outcomes and reducing the sport’s injury burden.

Keywords: Anterior cruciate ligament, Soccer Players, ACL

Introduction

The anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) is a key ligament in the knee that provides stability and regulates excessive mobility. ACL injuries are common in sports that require rapid stops, changes of direction, or jumping. These injuries are common during sports such as soccer, basketball, football, and skiing. ACL injuries can range from minor sprains to severe tears that may necessitate surgical intervention for healing [1]. Soccer has a somewhat high incidence of ACL injuries due to the nature of the game, which includes swift changes of direction, turning, and sudden stops. According to studies, female soccer players are more likely to develop ACL injuries than their male counterparts. The incidence of ACL injuries in soccer varies according to age, gender, level of play, and playing surface [2].

Understanding the risk variables linked with ACL injuries in soccer is critical for developing effective preventative techniques. Poor neuromuscular control, muscle imbalances, prior injury, anatomical abnormalities, and playing circumstances are some of the most prominent risk factors for ACL injuries. By identifying these risk variables, coaches, athletes, and medical professionals can create tailored prevention programs to reduce ACL injuries. Neuromuscular training programs, proper warm-up and cool-down routines, strength training focusing on the lower extremities, balance and proprioception exercises, proper footwear and equipment use, and education of athletes on proper landing and cutting techniques are all potential prevention strategies for ACL injuries in soccer [3-5].

A proposed strategy for preventing ACL injuries recommends conducting biomechanical tests on athletes before and after preventive treatments are implemented. This includes on-the-field inspections while players conduct cutting motions in order to identify potential injury risks and modify prevention strategies appropriately. Despite widespread knowledge of ACL injury concerns in sports, injury prevention strategies for this demographic have been inconsistent due to ambiguous risk variables. To construct more specialized injury prevention measures, additional research is required to refine and develop effective prevention tactics targeted to the athletic group at risk.

ACL Injury Mechanisms

A non-contact ACL tear occurs when excessive stresses are applied to the knee ligament without any external contact, whereas a contact ACL rupture is caused by a collision. Non-contact injuries are more common and typically occur during deceleration and acceleration motions. According to studies, the ligament elongates during rapid deceleration, which increases strain. Balance training and modified change of direction techniques are effective therapies for reducing strain and injury risk. High-risk maneuvers in soccer include deceleration before sidestepping and landing from jumps. Analyzing kinematics, kinetics, and muscle activation patterns aids in the identification of causes that strain the ACL and guides preventative measures. However, there are inconsistent findings in the literature regarding risk factors and the effectiveness of preventative interventions [3,5-8].

Kinematics and Kinetics

Kinematic and kinetic values are essential in understanding the movements and forces acting on the body. Motion occurs in three planes: frontal, sagittal, and transverse, represented by adduction/abduction, flexion/extension, and internal/external rotation. Multiplanar analysis is proposed as the most effective way to predict injury risk, with most studies supporting multiplanar conditions as more likely to cause injuries. Mechanisms of injury within each plane should be understood, such as valgus/varus stresses in the frontal plane and limited hip/knee flexion in the sagittal plane.Frontal plane kinematics, specifically valgus alignment, at both initial and peak contact in landing have been identified as significant predictors of injury risk. However, there are differing opinions on the effects of knee abduction on ACL injury, as the medial collateral ligament (MCL) primarily resists valgus moments. Limited hip and knee flexion in the sagittal plane has consistently been associated with injury risk, and studies have found that knee position close to full extension during deceleration maneuvers is a common factor in non-contact ACL injuries. In the transverse plane, internal tibial rotation has been shown to result in higher ACL strain compared to external rotation, but external rotation also has the potential to damage the ligament, particularly in weight-bearing situations. Further research is needed to fully elucidate these risk factors and their interactions, especially in sport-specific populations and movements [3,9-13].

Methodology

For this systematic review focusing on Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) injuries in soccer players, a comprehensive search strategy was employed to identify relevant studies. The primary database utilized for this review was PubMed due to its extensive coverage of biomedical literature. The search approach was designed to include keywords relating to ACL injuries, soccer players, risk factors, and prevention techniques. The following search terms were used: "Anterior Cruciate Ligament injury," "ACL injury," "soccer players," "football players," "risk factors," and "prevention strategies," which were combined using Boolean operators to refine the search results.

Specific criteria were used to select publications for inclusion in this review to ensure the research's relevance and quality. The studies selected had to be published in peer-reviewed journals and largely focus on ACL injuries in soccer players, with an emphasis on risk factors and prevention techniques. To ensure uniformity and accessibility, all selected articles had to be written in English. Articles that did not fulfill the given criteria or were not available in full-text format were omitted from consideration throughout the review process. A detailed selection approach was carried out using PubMed, resulting in the discovery of 30 publications that closely related to the research topic. This extensive selection procedure began with screening candidate articles' titles and abstracts, followed by a thorough assessment of the entire texts to determine their eligibility based on the defined inclusion and exclusion criteria. Furthermore, cross-referencing was used to guarantee that the issue was covered thoroughly and to validate the relevance and authenticity of the selected articles.

The systematic extraction of data from the selected papers entailed obtaining critical information such as study characteristics, sample size, methodology, and notable findings on both risk factors and preventative techniques for ACL injuries in soccer players. This methodological methodology intended to synthesis the gathered data in order to provide a comprehensive overview of ACL injuries in this specific group of athletes. The integration of this knowledge, which focuses on common risk factors and evidence-based prevention techniques, will help to provide a full grasp of the issue.

Results

The systematic analysis of 30 studies on ACL injuries in soccer players gives important insights into the incidence, risk factors, and prevention techniques for these injuries. According to the findings, ACL injuries are more common in older age groups among young male soccer players. This finding underscores the importance of age-appropriate injury prevention interventions in this population. Non-contact injuries were discovered to be widespread among professional male soccer players, occurring during activities such as pressing, dribbling, and tackle. These findings highlight the necessity of addressing biomechanical aspects and movement patterns in training and preventative programs. According to the analysis, a high proportion of ACL ruptures in professional soccer players require surgical reconstruction. However, the majority of athletes were able to resume training in a reasonably short period of time and maintained their pre-injury performance levels three years later.

Female soccer players had a higher frequency of ACL injuries than males, indicating that they were more susceptible. This emphasizes the significance of creating gender-specific risk assessment and preventative measures for ACL injuries in soccer. The analysis highlights the efficacy of multi-component preventative programs, such as plyometrics, strength exercises, and preseason/in-season training, in minimizing ACL injuries in soccer players. Specific programs, such as FIFA 11+, have shown a considerable reduction in knee injuries, particularly ACL injuries, when administered correctly. Biomechanical study reveals that knee valgus loads and hip/knee flexion angles during landing lead to ACL damage. Training methods that address these aspects, such as pelvic and core strength training, have resulted in improved landing biomechanics and jump height. Soccer players' successful rehabilitation after ACL damage and reconstruction has been linked to positive communication, self-belief, goal-setting, and clear goals. These psychological elements are critical to supporting the rehabilitation process and getting the best possible outcomes (Table 1).

Biomedical Science &, Research

Table 1: Overview of Previous Studies on ACL Injuries in Soccer Players

These findings underline the importance of ACL injuries in soccer and the necessity for comprehensive preventative efforts that take into account age, gender, biomechanical parameters, and psychological elements of recovery. By implementing evidence-based preventative programs and customizing them to soccer players' unique requirements, the incidence and impact of ACL injuries can be reduced, eventually improving athletes' long-term results.

Discussion

The findings of this systematic study shed light on Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) injuries in soccer players, identifying key risk variables and efficient prevention techniques. ACL injuries were observed to be more common in later age groups among young male soccer players, stressing the importance of age-appropriate preventative strategies. Non-contact injuries were found to be common in professional male players during activities such as pressing, dribbling, and tackling, highlighting the necessity of addressing biomechanics and movement patterns in training and preventative programs.

A systematic assessment of ACL injuries in soccer players found numerous important risk variables for these injuries. Older age groups had a higher rate of ACL injuries among young male soccer players, emphasizing the necessity of age-appropriate preventative approaches. Non-contact injuries during activities like as pressing, dribbling, and tackling were widespread among elite male athletes, highlighting the importance of addressing biomechanical components and movement patterns in training and preventative programs. Gender differences were found, with females having a higher incidence of ACL injuries. Multi-component preventative programs, such as plyometrics and strength exercises, were found to be beneficial in decreasing ACL tears. Improving preventive outcomes requires tailoring prevention techniques to individual criteria such as age, anatomical anomalies, and previous injuries. Overall, identifying these risk variables is critical for developing evidence-based and personalised prevention programmes to lower the frequency of ACL injuries in soccer players [2,5-7].

ACL injuries are managed in a variety of ways, including nonoperative management, ACL repair, reconstruction with various graft types, anatomic reconstruction, tunnel drilling techniques, fixation methods, and the potential use of internal bracing, ALL reconstruction, and biologic agents. Pre and postoperative rehabilitation are critical components of the management process, and the timing of return to play must be carefully considered and assessed on an individual basis. Treatment options are determined by patient characteristics, tear pattern, and surgeon expertise, and continued research is necessary to develop and optimize management procedures for ACL injuries.

Nonoperative management of ACL tears is crucial to prevent recurrent instability and additional knee injuries. Structured rehabilitation programs are used to strengthen surrounding muscles and improve knee stability. ACL repair involves re-approximating the torn ends of the native ACL using sutures or suture anchors, aiming to preserve the native ligament and promote healing. ACL reconstruction involves creating a new ligament using grafts such as Hamstring Tendon (HT), Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone (BPTB), or Quadriceps Tendon (QT). Anatomic reconstruction aims to restore the native ACL footprint on both the tibial and femoral sides of the knee, taking into account the individual anatomy of the patient. Tunnel drilling techniques for ACL reconstruction have evolved, with a shift away from transtibial drilling towards outside-in techniques or using guides placed through the anteromedial portal. Fixation methods and graft types are not clear, and patient selection is critical. Anterolateral Ligament (ALL) reconstruction may be considered in conjunction with ACL repair or reconstruction. Biologic agents like Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) and stem cells are being investigated in ACL repair and reconstruction [44-51].

The study discovered that the cost burden of (ACL) reconstructions for amateur football players in Australia is significant, estimated Anterior Cruciate Ligament at $A69,623,211 year. The average overall cost of an ACL reconstruction is $A34,079, with indirect expenditures accounting for the bulk. The mean indirect expenses are 19.8% greater than the mean direct expenditures, but lower among female and junior players. ACL expenditures are three to four times higher than osteoarthritis costs. However, according to the report, emphasizing injury prevention programs might result in large cost savings, with an estimated $A9,460,224 saved for every 10% increase in adherence to such programs. These findings emphasize the importance of injury prevention and its potential impact on lowering the financial burden of ACL repairs in amateur football players [52].

Soccer players can reduce ACL injuries through multi-component preventative programs like plyometrics, strength exercises, and preseason/in-season training. The FIFA 11+ program has shown promising results in minimizing knee injuries. Training strategies targeting knee valgus loads and hip/knee flexion angles improve landing biomechanics and jump height. Positive communication, self-belief, goal-setting, and defined goals facilitate successful rehabilitation. Neuromuscular training can modify risk factors in female athletes, but studies are inconsistent. Targeting high-risk athletes may improve prevention efficiency [53,54].

However, it is vital to recognize several limitations in the present corpus of literature. There is a need for further high-quality research into ACL injury risk factors and prevention measures in soccer players, particularly women. The variety in study designs, sample sizes, and outcome measures across the included studies makes it difficult to make direct comparisons and draw firm conclusions. Future study should try to address these limitations while also refining and optimizing preventative techniques for ACL injuries among soccer players.

Overall, this systematic review emphasizes the importance of ACL injuries in soccer and the necessity for comprehensive prevention measures that take into account age, gender, biomechanical parameters, and psychological elements of rehabilitation. The incidence and severity of ACL injuries can be lowered by implementing evidence-based preventative programs customized to the specific needs of soccer players, resulting in better long-term outcomes for athletes.

Conclusion

This systematic review explores the prevalence, risk factors, and prevention strategies for ACL injuries in soccer players. It emphasizes the need for age-appropriate and gender-specific interventions, as well as multi-component prevention programs incorporating plyometrics and strength exercises. The review also highlights the influence of psychological factors on rehabilitation and long-term athlete outcomes. Further research is needed to refine prevention strategies and tailor interventions to individual needs. Evidence-based prevention programs can help minimize ACL injuries and improve overall well-being and performance.

Acknowledgement

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

Sign up for Newsletter

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest updates. We respect your privacy and will never share your email address with anyone else.